The conclusion of Timothy Gowers & Mohan Ganesalingam’s experiment.
I have now closed the polls in the second mathematical writing experiment. Here are the results. I have also published the comments on the first and second experiments, which shed further light on the results and on (some) people’s reasons for voting the way they did.
The results were complicated slightly by the fact that after a couple of days the post was linked to from the front page of Hacker News, and suddenly the number of people who voted more than tripled in a few hours. Furthermore, there was a bit of discussion about the polls, so it is not clear that the votes were completely independent. Also, the profile of an average Hacker News reader is probably somewhat different from the profile of an average reader of this blog.
Fortunately, I had recorded the votes shortly before this happened, so below we (“we” means Mohan Ganesalingam and I)…
View original post 5,780 more words